Showing posts with label NFL Draft. Show all posts
Showing posts with label NFL Draft. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 27, 2021

2021 NFL Mock Draft

 It’s NFL Draft week, which means it’s time for the annual tradition of filling out a mock that will go down in flames within the first hour. 





1. Jacksonville Jaguars: Trevor Lawrence, QB, Clemson - This card was turned in months ago. Even if he doesn’t live up to the John Elway/Andrew Luck comps, he’s already one of the three best QB’s in franchise history.

2. New York Jets: Zach Wilson, QB, BYU - Along with Lawrence going to the Jags, the only other mortal lock are the Jets taking Wilson, who will look to succeed were predecessors Mark Sanchez and Sam Darnold failed.

3. San Francisco 49ers (from MIA via HOU): Mac Jones, QB, Alabama - It’s weird that San Fran traded up to get Jones, who seemed destined to go lower, but the team loves his accuracy. Trey Lance is also in the mix. 

4. Atlanta Falcons: Kyle Pitts, TE, Florida - This is Atlanta’s best chance to take a QB, but Matt Ryan still has a few years left in a league where passers play into their 40’s. If the Falcons do trade Julio Jones, they’ll need a new weapon and Pitts might be the best in the draft. 

5. Cincinnati Bengals: Ja’Marr Chase, WR, LSU - It would make more sense for Cincy to get more protection for Joe Burrow, coming off a rookie season cut short by a torn ACL, but the team seems to be adamant on reuniting Burrow with his former college teammate Chase. 

6. Miami Dolphins (from PHI): Jaylen Waddle, WR, Alabama - The Dolphins need to prioritize building around Tua. They could use an elite blindside protector like Penei Sewell but adding the speedy Waddle to DeVante Parker and Will Fuller helps, too.

TRADE! Detroit trades pick to New England: With two of the top WR off the board, Detroit takes advantage of New England’s desperation for a QB and moves down.


7. New England Patriots (from DET): Justin Fields, QB, Ohio State - The Patriots addressed a number of needs with their free agency spending spree but they still need a quarterback and they aren’t getting one of the top five sitting at 15. Even if Cam Newton bounces back from a horrid 2020, he’s not the long-term answer. Fields can learn behind Cam in Year 1 and take over in 2022.


TRADE! Carolina trades pick to Los Angeles Chargers: The Panthers need to recoup some picks after trading for Sam Darnold. The Chargers, needing offensive line help, pounce at the opportunity to get a franchise left tackle. 


8. Los Angeles Chargers (from CAR): Penei Sewell, OT, Oregon - In a draft that could see a lot of college reunions, the Chargers invest in Justin Herbert’s future by drafting his old left tackle. Sewell drew Jonathan Ogden comps from legendary scout Gil Brandt and could go as high as 4, but the run on QBs likely causes him to slip.


9. Denver Broncos: Trey Lance, QB, North Dakota State - Giving up on Drew Lock after a season and a half seems like a mistake but the same can be said about passing on an opportunity to upgrade at the sport’s most important position. The Broncos have holes elsewhere but Lance is both the best player available and fills a huge need. 


10. Dallas Cowboys: Patrick Surtain II, CB, Alabama - You could slot any defensive player in here and it would be an upgrade for a unit that hemorrhaged points last year. Surtain is the best corner in this draft, is arguably the best overall defensive prospect and his father was a Pro Bowl corner with the Dolphins. After signing Dak Prescott to a $240 million contract, using this pick to improve the offensive line is an option as well. 


11. New York Giants: Kwity Paye, Edge, Michigan: The Giants spent big money fixing both sides of the ball this offseason, but still need a pass-rusher in a division that features Dak Prescott and Jalen Hurts. Paye might seem like a reach here but GM Dave Gettleman has been against trading down over the years and isn’t afraid to take his guy earlier than expected (See Jones, Daniel).


12. Philadelphia Eagles (from MIA via SF): DaVonta Smith, WR, Alabama - The Eagles’ offense lost Alshon Jeffrey, DeSean Jackson and will eventually trade Zach Ertz, leaving Dallas Goedert and last year’s first round pick Jalen Raegor as Jalen Hurt’s only weapons. Smith’s skinny frame raises some concerns that might cause him to drop but the reigning Heisman trophy winner was unstoppable this past season and he could be a dynamic playmaker if he bulks up. 


13. Detroit Lions (from LAC): Micah Parsons, LB, Penn State - The Lions badly need a wide receiver after letting Kenny Golladay and Marvin Jones walk. In this scenario, they miss out on the top three but wind up with Parsons, a potential top-five prospect from “Linebacker U” who could fall because maturity concerns and off-the-field issues. 


14. Minnesota Vikings: Rashawn Slater, OT, Northwestern - The Vikings’ offensive line was a mess even before losing tackle Riley Reiff. Enter Slater, who took last season off due to the pandemic but had dominant moments against the Big 10’s best. 


15. Carolina Panthers (from NE): Jaycee Horn, CB, South Carolina - The Panthers could help Sam Darnold out by improving the O-Line and giving him time to throw, but in a pass-happy NFC South, you can never have too many quality defensive backs. 


TRADE! Arizona trades pick to Washington: Washington has needs at quarterback, linebacker and along the offensive line but they’ll have to move up to snag a quality option. 


16. Washington Football Team (from ARZ): Christian Darrasaw, OT, Virginia Tech - Washington needs a QB badly but might find the price to move into the top 10 too expensive. Darrasaw isn’t as polished as Sewell or Slater but he’s a fine pass protector who will make Ryan Fitzpatrick’s job a little easier. (Note: As this was being written, WFT acquired Ereck Flowers from Miami. That shouldn't change Washington's need for line help.


17. Las Vegas Raiders: Alijah Vera-Tucker, G/T, USC - There’s been a disconnect between what the Raiders should do and what they wind up doing on draft day during the Mike Mayock/Jon Gruden era. Every time you have an idea where they are leaning, you wind up with a Clelin Ferrell or Damon Arnotte. Vegas lost Gabe Jackson and Trent Brown off their offensive line. So, taking the versatile Vera-Tucker, who can play guard or tackle, would make sense.


18. Miami Dolphins: Jaelen Phillips, DE, Miami - The Phins’ defense made strides last season and now stay local with Phillips, a big man (6’5, 266lbs) with a long wingspan whose work against the run and pass will make him a Brian Flores’ favorite.


19. Arizona Cardinals (from WSH): Caleb Farley, CB, Virginia Tech - This year’s Jeffrey Simmons. Off talent alone, Farley is a top-10 pick but back surgery in March will cause him to drop. Meanwhile, the Cardinals need a replacement for Patrick Peterson and might find Farley’s upside worth the wait.


20. Chicago Bears: Greg Newsome, CB, Northwestern - The Bears released top corner Kyle Fuller and will attempt to replace him with the aging Desmond Trufant. Even if the 32-year-old can turn back the clock, the unit needs an influx of young talent and staying in-state with Newsome makes sense. 


21. Indianapolis Colts: Jalen Mayfield, OT, Michigan - The Colts could go with any of the half dozen pass rushers left on the board, but for the Carson Wentz project to work out, he needs to feel safe in the pocket. Mayfield could replace the retiring Anthony Costanzo at left tackle and leave All-Pro guard Quentin Nelson at his natural spot.


22. Tennessee Titans: Asante Samuel Jr, CB, Florida State - The Titans lost Malcolm Butler and Adoree Jackson in the offseason, replacing them with short-term fixed Janoris Jenkins and Kevin Johnson. Titans coach Mike Vrabel played in New England with Asante Sr and should be impressed by Junior’s ability to cover and defend the run. 


23. New York Jets (from SEA): Gregory Rousseau, DE, Miami - Gang Green has ignored its need for a pass-rusher during past regimes but would be wise not to make the same mistake with new head coach Robert Salah at the helm. Rousseau took 2020 off but is a giant (6’6, 260) with even bigger upside. He’ll fit right in opposite Carl Lawson on the outside. 


24. Pittsburgh Steelers: Najee Harris, RB, Alabama - One of the last teams still committed to the run, Pittsburgh hasn’t hid its desire to find a new bellcow after letting James Conner walk. Alabama has been a running back factory lately with Derrick Henry and Josh Jacobs’ recent star turns. If not the bruising Harris, the Steelers could opt for Clemson’s Travis Etienne, who is more of a versatile home run threat. 


25. Jacksonville Jaguars (from LAR): Trevon Moehrig, DB, TCU - The Jags could go a number of directions here but fill their needs at corner and safety with Moehrig, who can play either spot. 


26. Cleveland Browns: Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah, ILB, Notre Dame - The Browns filled their need for a pass-rusher opposite Myles Garrett by rolling the dice on Jadaveon Clowney. Now, the team continues to improve their front seven with Owusu-Koramoah, who excels in pass coverage while remaining a force against the run. 


27. Baltimore Ravens: Rashod Bateman, WR, Minnesota: The Ravens claim to be content with their receiving core but Marquise Brown is undersized and Sammy Watkins can’t stay healthy. If nothing else, the 6’2” Bateman gives the Ravens another red-zone threat while also acting as Watkins insurance on the outside. 


28. New Orleans Saints: Zaven Collins, LB, Tulsa - This is prime trade-out-of-the-first-round territory, so don’t be surprised if the Saints opt out of Day 1. If they don’t, adding to their weak linebacking core would be a sound decision. 


29. Green Bay Packers: Christian Barmore, DT, Alabama - After another quiet offseason, the Packers are going to be under the gun to get Aaron Rodgers more help. Unfortunately, many of the top options are gone and Green Bay has fared better finding their receivers in round two (Davante Adams, Jordy Nelson, Randall Cobb) anyway. Barmore is the best of a poor interior defensive lineman group and would fit in nicely alongside Kenny Clark up front. As for Rodgers, the Packers dangling heir apparent Jordan Love in a trade for Julio Jones would save the team some headaches. 


30. Buffalo Bills: Jayson Oweh, Edge, Penn State - The Bills’ pass rush is a sore spot in desperate need of speed as defensive ends Jerry Hughes (33) as Mario Addison (34) are getting long in the tooth. The 22-year-old Oweh checks all the boxes as a 6’5” 257-pound freak of nature who ran a 4.3 40 and notched 13.5 sacks in 20 games during his time at Penn State.


31. Baltimore Ravens (from KC): Landon Dickerson, C, Alabama - The Ravens could look for help on the offensive line after trading Orlando Brown to Kansas City in order to nab this spot. Dickerson joins Kevin Zeitler on Baltimore’s revamped interior. A pass rusher like Georgia’s Azeez Ojulari or Texas’ Joseph Ossai could get the call here, too. 


TRADE! Tampa Bay trades pick to Miami: With all 22 starters from their Super Bowl-winning squad returning, the Bucs don’t have many needs to address. Meanwhile, the Dolphins have plenty of ammo to acquire a third first-round pick. 


32. Miami Dolphins (from TB): Travis Etienne, RB, Clemson - The Dolphins have one of the worst running back groups in the league led by Myles Gaskin and Malcolm Brown. With three other RB-needy teams ahead of them in round 2 (Jags, Jets, Falcons), Miami don’t wait for a runner to fall to 36 and move up for arguably the best back in the draft in Etienne.  

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

Dumb Honest Question of the Week: Who's #1?

Lost in all of the hoopla over the NFL lockout is the fact that the NFL Draft is just over a month away. Unlike most years, the lack of a true blue alpha dog at the top gives us a bit of uncertainty as to who will be taken by the Carolina Panthers with the #1 overall pick.

This is an issue that me and my buddy Carlos have been going back and forth on. After months of vitriol towards Auburn's Heisman-winning QB Cam Newton, Carlos switched sides pretty much directly after the Combine and has given Cam a vigorous co-sign as the Panthers' franchise QB. I, on the other hand, think the Panthers are better served to look outside the QB position, snatch up one of the Draft's better prospects(I'm high on Georgia WR A.J. Green, personally), given current incumbent Jimmy Clausen another year and then go all in for Andrew Luck next year if Clausen tanks yet again. The debate between me and Carlos has raged for weeks and I finally decided to say "Screw it!" and manifest this topic into a more public forum.

So, in the triumphant return of the "Dumb Honest Question of the Week", I ask, whole-heartedly, do the Carolina Panthers NEED to take a QB with the first overall pick?




Now, my answer is no. For one, as bad as Clausen was last year as the Panthers QB (3 TDs, 9 INTs, 1,558 yards, 58.4 QB rating in 11 starts), keep in mind that you're closing the book on a 23-year old kid who has 11 starts to his name on a team that was battered, beat up and mailing it in by midseason. I'm not saying Jimmy Clausen is the second coming of Joe Montana, but we've seen teams give up on young QBs early for what they believed to be better alternatives only for the departed youngster to go on to bigger things. It happened in 2004 when the arrival of Phillip Rivers as the Chargers' first round pick lit a fire under the ass of Drew Brees(Granted, the move worked out for both men. Brees went on to win a Super Bowl lighting it up in New Orleans while Rivers has been a Pro Bowl QB in San Diego. Still, you wonder what would have happened had San Diego opted for, say, Pittsburgh WR Larry Fitzgerald and held on to Brees. Would we be thinking of the Chargers differently if they had spent the last half decade with a foursome of Brees-L.T.-Fitzgerald-Antonio Gates? I guess we'll never know.). A couple years ago, the Bears swapped Kyle Orton for what they believed to be an upgrade in Jay Cutler. Orton went on to be a solid QB in Denver while Cutler has been shaky to say the least.


What's the risk of giving Clausen one more year and, if you're going to give up on Clausen, why not replace him with a veteran rather than roll the dice on yet another inexperienced rookie QB? Both Newton and Blaine Gabbert are better options, on paper, than Clausen but are they head and shoulders better? I don't think so. Bengals QB Carson Palmer, who is desperately seeking a way out of Cincinatti, is a big upgrade over Clausen. Yes, he's 31, coming off a terrible season and is owed $10 million for 2011 but he's a veteran whose best years aren't THAT far behind him(2005 and 2006 being his best seasons). How about Kevin Kolb? Now, word on the street is the Eagles have found a team willing to give up a first(supposedly Arizona) for Kolb's services. If that's the case, it may be worth it to pass on the 26-year old Eagles backup because the first overall pick is a bit much for a guy with a less-than-stellar track record. If the price comes down though, Kolb would be a great fit. Another cheap option: Packers backup Matt Flynn. Even as a Packers fan, I worry that Flynn is nothing more than this generation's Jay Fiedler but he played admirable in his only start of his career and he'll come at a much lower price than Palmer or Kolb or Newton and Gabbert. He could be a decent starter. If nothing else, he can give Clausen work until next year when the Panthers will be in the running for Andrew Luck.






By tabbing a veteran at QB, the Panthers can shift focus to another one of their many needs. A.J. Green has been considered by some to be the best WR prospect since Fitzgerald and has already drawn Randy Moss/Andre Johnson comparisons. You pair him with Steve Smith and newly acquired TE Jeremy Shockey to go with the backfield of Jonathan Stewart and Mike Goodson and your offense is improved significantly.




On the other side of the ball, there are a bunch of other highly-touted prospects. Clemson DE Da'Quan Bowers is big, athletic defensive end. The kind of beast the Panthers had when they had a similar-sized freak in Julius Peppers. In a division with pass-happy teams like New Orleans and Atlanta, a pass rusher the caliber of Bowers would pay dividends for the Panthers. At a position where talent is a bit more rare to find, there's defensive tackles Marcell Dareus of Alabama and Auburn's Nick Fairley. Dareus outplayed Fairley(considered the top DT in the draft going into the Combine) at the NFL Combine but Fairley bounced back with an impressive pro day. Both can be disruptive forces on the interior(as Fairley proved in the National Championship) and both significantly upgrade a position that hasn't had something close to adequate since Kris Jenkins was traded. Now, all three defensive standouts come with their red flags. Bowers has been battling an injury with his knee that required surgery in January. Fairley has had issues with his weight and some concerns over his character and Dareus has had some character issues as well. All three men also have the stigma of being one-year wonders, but the same can be said for Newton and Gabbert.





That brings me back to Carlos' case. According to Carlos, Cam Newton has the size, speed, athletic ability and, most importantly, leadership ability to be a difference maker for Carolina. Carlos believes there isn't a QB in the draft or available in trade that he'd take over Cam Newton(Editor's note: When I texted Carlos to clarify his stance, he softened a little saying he would consider trading a 3rd for Kolb but that's it). If the Panthers were to go QB, I would prefer they go Newton over Gabbert even with Newton not looking the sharpest in throwing drills at the Combine(The fact that he was willing to participate in those drills knowing what he may lose if he failed is something that earned him props from both me and Carlos, especially since Gabbert waited til his Pro Day to show off his arm) for the exact same reasons as Carlos. I think Newton will be a fine QB if given time to sit and learn(preferably from a vet) before jumping into being a starter. Newton doesn't have much experience with a pro-style offense(or really being a starter, for that much) and it's a lot of pressure to thrust a young guy in there and tell him to save a franchise. Yes, it worked for Sam Bradford and Matt Ryan. It also didn't work for Ryan Leaf, Akili Smith, Cade McNown, Matt Leinart and David Carr. The same holds true for Gabbert, who played in a spread offense at Missouri for two years. The scouts are high on Gabbert and he's certianly in the running to bypass Newton as the Panthers' pick, but there's just something I don't like about him(He did only have 16 TDs last season with the Tigers and his bowl game against Iowa wasn't the greatest either). It's just a hunch. Granted, it's the same hunch that thought Ryan and Bradford would flop and Joey Harrington would flourish but whatever.




So, in conclusion, my strategy is I were running the Panthers next month would be this: Take A.J. Green with the #1 overall pick. Yes, it's unconventional and the four-game suspension to start off his final season at Georgia was a bit of a red flag but the guy has all the makings of being a star in this league(I like Green over Bowers or Fairley or Dareus just slightly. Though I think all four are better prospects than Newton. Still, I would rank Newton 6th, behind these four and LSU CB Patrick Patterson). After you draft Green, get Clausen some veteran competition. Marc Bulger wants another crack at starting. Tarvaris Jackson or Dennis Dixon could be interesting(both free agents) or you could take a flier on Palmer or Flynn(Kolb is probably out of the running if the Cardinals are willing to give up the 5th pick in the draft for him). You could try trading back and getting back that second round pick you gave away to New England last year but that might be farfetched. You go into next season(if there is one) with a healthy offensive line, a two-pronged running attack and some solid weapons for whoever is behind center. Yes, defense wins championships but this team is years away from that(especially in that division). If all else fails, you're right back on top of the draft next year and you get Andrew Luck. Newton and Gabbert are good QB prospects. They don't get this team out of picking in the Top 10 next year or probably even 2013. Clausen is worth another year at starter and, while Newton and Gabbert are upgrades, they aren't big enough upgrades to bypass the other value you can get at this spot or blowing the chance at taking your QB too early when you're probably picking high again next year.

Sunday, February 6, 2011

Dumb Honest Question of the Week

One would think that picking in the Top 10 of the NFL Draft should make you more likely to improve on the upcoming season because, in theory, you have more of a selection of the best talent than the team picking, say, 26th. However, that hasn't been the case for quite some time now. The Detroit Lions have picked in the Top 10 for seven of the last ten years and they couldn't sniff the playoffs with Erin Andrews' nose. Cleveland has made the playoffs once, despite picking in the Top 10 eight times since their return to the NFL in 1999(they didn't have a 1st round pick in 2008, and they traded out of the top 5 in 2009 when they passed up on Mark Sanchez to move down and take center Alex Mack).

That leads us to this week's Dumb Honest Question.....

....Is it worth it to pick in the Top 10 of the NFL Draft anymore?

Critics will point to the exuberant rookie contracts handed out to Top 10 picks hamstringing salary cap strapped teams. Certainly, that theory has some merit, but the high failure rate of these high picks is more the cause than their hefty salaries. Is JaMarcus Russell's contract such a backbreaker if he's a 2-time Pro Bowl QB leading the Raiders to back-to-back AFC West titles instead of a Purple Drank-slurping, fat lard who can't even score a job in the UFL? Bad management is the root cause for teams routinely picking high every year. Case and point, Matt Millen, who crippled the Lions with bad pick after bad pick year in and year out. Do we think differently of Detroit if Millen hits on Charles Rogers and Joey Harrington? Probably, but he didn't so we don't. Regardless, teams are striking out at a rate that would make Mark Reynolds squeamish. In the last year's draft, only two teams picking in the Top 10 made the playoffs(Kansas City and Seattle, and the Seahawks made it with a 7-9 record). The year before, the same result: 2(although you can make the case for 3, since the Jets technically picked in the Top 5 after trading up to take Sanchez. The Bengals and Packers are the others).

Conversely, teams that routinely pick near the end of the Draft have done well for themselves. A lot of that can be attributed to front office savvy and their success in hitting on later round picks but it's still dumbfounding that teams picking at the bottom are outdoing their higher-picking counterparts. After all, this isn't fantasy football. We aren't running a snake draft here where teams picking at the end in Round 1 go on to pick early in Round 2. To take this case deeper, here's a look at all 12 playoff teams, their top 5 players and where they were picked:

AFC

1. New England Patriots

a. Tom Brady(6th round, 2000)
b. Wes Welker(undrafted free agent, acquired from Miami for a 2nd round pick)
c. Vince Wilfork(21st overall pick, 2004)
d. Logan Mankins(32nd overall pick, 2005)
e. Devin McCourtey(27th overall pick, 2010)

2. Pittsburgh Steelers

a. Ben Roethlisberger(11th overall pick, 2004)
b. Troy Polamalu(16th overall pick, 2003)
c. James Harrison(undrafted)
d. Casey Hampton(19th overall pick, 2001)
e. Hines Ward(3rd round, 1998)

3. Indianapolis Colts

a. Peyton Manning(1st overall, 1998)
b. Dwight Freeney (11th overall, 2002)
c. Reggie Wayne (30th overall, 2001)
d. Dallas Clark (24th overall, 2003)
e. Bob Sanders (2nd round, 2004)

4. Kansas City Chiefs

a. Jamaal Charles(3rd round, 2008)
b. Dwayne Bowe (23rd overall, 2007)
c. Matt Cassel (7th round pick by New England in 2005, acquired for a 2nd round pick)
d. Eric Berry(5th overall pick, 2010)
e. Brandon Flowers(2nd round pick, 2008)

5. Baltimore Ravens

a. Ray Lewis(26th overall, 1996)
b. Ed Reed (24th overall, 2002)
c. Haloti Ngata(12th overall, 2006)
d. Terrell Suggs(10th overall, 2003)
e. Ray Rice (2nd round, 2008)

(Editor's Note: There are few things I am more certain of than my friend Carlos reading the Ravens rankings and taking issue with the order. I'd bet money on it.)

6. New York Jets

a. Darrelle Revis(14th overall, 2007)
b. Santonio Holmes(25th overall by Pittsburgh in 2006, acquired for a 5th round pick)
c. David Harris(2nd round, 2007)
d. Mark Sanchez(5th overall, 2009)
e. Nick Mangold(29th overall, 2006)

NFC

1. Atlanta Falcons

a. Matt Ryan(3rd overall, 2008)
b. Roddy White(27th overall, 2005)
c. Michael Turner(5th round pick, 2004 by SD, signed by ATL in 2008)
d. John Abraham(13th overall pick by NYJ, 2000)
e. Tony Gonzalez(13th overall pick by KC in 1997, acquired for 2nd round pick)

2. Chicago Bears

a. Brian Urlacher(9th overall, 2000)
b. Julius Peppers(2nd overall pick, 2002, by Carolina, signed as a free agent in 2010)
c. Jay Cutler(11th overall, 2006, by Denver, acquired for multiple picks in 2009)
d. Matt Forte(2nd round, 2008)
e. Lance Briggs(3rd round, 2003)

3. Philadelphia Eagles

a. DeSean Jackson(2nd round, 2008)
b. Michael Vick(1st overall, 2001, signed as free agent in 2009)
c. Trent Cole(5th round, 2005)
d. Asante Samuel(4th round, 2003 by NE, signed as a free agent in 2008)
e. Jeremy Maclin(19th overall, 2009)

4. Seattle Seahawks

a. Matt Hasselbeck(6th round, 1998, by GB, acquired for a swap of first round picks in 2001)
b. Lofa Tatupu(2nd round, 2005)
c. Earl Thomas(14th overall, 2010)
d. Mike Williams(10th overall, 2005 by Detroit, signed by Seattle in 2010)
e. Marshawn Lynch(12th overall, 2007, by Buffalo, acquired for 4th round pick)

5. New Orleans Saints

a. Drew Brees(2nd round pick, 2001, signed as free agent in 2006)
b. Marques Colston(7th round, 2006)
c. Jonathan Vilma(12th overall, 2004, by NYJ, acquired for a conditional draft pick)
d. Darren Sharper(2nd round pick, 1997, by GB, signed as free agent in 2009)
e. Lance Moore(undrafted)

6. Green Bay Packers

a. Aaron Rodgers(24th overall, 2005)
b. Clay Matthews(26th overall, 2009)
c. Greg Jennings (2nd round pick, 2006)
d. Charles Woodson(4th overall pick, by Oakland, in 1998, signed as free agent in 2006)
e. Tramon Williams(undrafted)

12 teams. 60 players. 10 of them picked in the Top 10. Four of the 10 became bigger stars on a team that didn't draft them(though I wouldn't classify Mike Williams as a "star", per se.). What gives? Obviously, luck is a factor in all of these picks. Some guys just need the right system and the right coaching to succeed. Clay Matthews didn't play a snap in high school, hardly saw action in college and dropped in the draft amidst steroid allegations. He lands with Green Bay, hooks up with Kevin Greene and Dom Capers and is now, to me, the best pass rusher in the sport. Still, this list should serve as a cautionary tale to the teams picking in the Top 10 come April. Yes, a Matt Ryan or a Sam Bradford can turn around your franchise, but the chances of that happening seem to be bleaker and bleaker as years pass. This year, there's no guy you would classify as a can't-miss, making the odds that more than 20% of the teams picking 1-10 making the playoffs next season all the more difficult. Can a Nick Fairley rejuvenate the Panthers? Could Patrick Patterson get Denver over the hump? Is Cam Newton the missing piece in Washington? Only time will tell. However, if this year's playoffs are any indication, GMs sitting at the top of the Draft may want to work those phones early in hopes of waiting a little longer for their rookie cornerstone.

Tuesday, April 28, 2009

My Mini Wrap-up


I had hoped to be writing this blog about the teams that I love, the New York Giants and the James Madison University Dukes.

Sadly (or with much delight if you're name is Dave), no JMU Dukes were taken in the draft or signed as a free agent afterwards. The fact that none were drafted does not surprise me. But I am surprised that no Duke was signed as a free agent, especially because a few were drawing some attention.

I considered analyzing my hometown team, the Virginia Cavaliers, and their players that were selected, but I can't even pretend to care enough.

So I'll move on and comment a little on what my New York Giants did at the draft.


(Blog intermission: I was in NYC during the weekend of the draft and I met the World Champion.

Yup, that's me and Judah Friedlander outside out Stand Up NY. According to him, he was an all world kicker for Devry. Thanks to my friends Henri and Erin and all of the great people at the club. My wife and I had a great time.)

Looking at the Giants picks as a whole it is clear they came into the draft looking to do a few things: One, find a replacement for Plaxico Burress. Two, round out their linebacking corps. Three, find a running back so they can continue to have a three headed backfield monster. Four, find a pass catching tight end.

With trying to find a great reciever in mind, the Giants took Hakeem Nicks in the first round. I was puzzled. I know he has all of the tools to be a no. 1 eventually, but he is no Plaxico. Plax was unique. I was even more puzzled with this pick when they took Ramses Barden (from football factory Cal-Poly) in the third round. He is built just like Plax. (6'6" 230lbs.) Obviously this is the guy they want to catch jump balls in the red zone.

Here is my problem with this. The Giants have spent many high draft picks in recent years on receivers: Steve Smith, Mario Manningham, Sinorice Moss, David Tyree (although he was taken late). Super Bowl heroics aside, none of these guys have become great yet. It might be too early to tell with these guys, but many receivers breakout in their first three years. My point is, the best receiver the Giants have acquired in recent years was Plaxico, in a trade. Why didn't they do the same thing this year and trade their first rounder for Braylon Edwards? They could have still gotten the linebacker, running back, and other positions they needed.

All of that being said, the picks of TE Travis Beckum in the third round and Andre Brown in the fourth round were huge value picks. Taking a flyer on Rhett Bomar is not a bad move either. He could develop into a solid back-up for Eli Manning, if not something more.

The Giants did an above average job in my book. They made some puzzling moves with their first two picks, but got great value from then on. Maybe next year a Duke will be taken.

- Gabe

Monday, April 27, 2009

Post-Draft Thoughts

In years past, I've followed NFL Draft weekend with the typical "Winners and Losers" piece, in which I praise those I believe to have done well on the last week of April and blast those who I feel did not. I've come to realize that it's a bit premature because you're essentially grading a team's draft on three components: Name recognition of the players selected, where in the draft said players were taken, and who else was available at the time those players were selected. The problem with this is you're passing judgement on an unfinished project. It would be like doing a movie critique on a trailer. Last year, I took the Falcons to task for selecting Matt Ryan because I felt he was a bit overhyped and thought Atlanta would have been better off with LSU DT Glenn Dorsey. A year later, Ryan's the reigning Rookie of the Year and the Dorsey briefly found himself on the trading block after an uninspiring rookie season. So, this year, I'm going the safer route and giving you who and what I liked from this past weekend's Draft. Is it much different from a "Winners and Losers" column? Probably not, but it's not nearly as bad as eating crow.

Thumbs Up:

1. Cincinatti Bengals: At first glance, I was a bit skeptical of a team that has had so much trouble keeping players out of the police blotter using its first 3 picks on guys with an acute case of knucklehead disease. However, when you take a deeper look at Andre Smith, Rey Maualuga, and Michael Johnson(all 3 of whom, were 1st round picks in my mock draft), you'll realize that they're guys who just need a bit of coaching up rather than the usual need for a parole officer. The Bengals walked out of this draft with a potential 6 starters out of their 11 picks overall(Smith, Maualuga, Johnson, center Jon Luigs, tight end Chase Coffman and punter Kevin Huber) which isn't bad for a team not far removed from being playoff contenders.

2. Philadelphia Eagles: Andy Reid and Co. hushed the critics who believed he would ignore surrounding QB Donovan McNabb with more weapons and stick to building the defense and aging offensive line. Reid came out firing before the draft, sending a late round 1st to Buffalo for Pro Bowl left tackle Jason Peters. Big Red then kept up the aggression by moving up to get speedy wide reciever Jeremy Maclin(whom some pegged as the top wideout in this draft). In the 2nd round, he replaced Correll Buckhalter with the highly underrated RB LeSean "Shady" McCoy and came up even bigger with two steals: Pass-catching tight end Cornelius Ingram and cornerback/return man Victor "Macho" Harris. Philly also swung a deal for disgruntled corner Ellis Hobbs, who along with Harris, could spell the last days for the also disgruntled Sheldon Brown. The cherry on top, however, was the team adding 3rd and 5th round picks in next year's draft, which could be used to snag Denver Broncos TE Tony Scheffler.

3. Jacksonville Jaguars: Give the Jags credit for lessons learned. With all-world WR Michael Crabtree still on the board at # 8, the Jags(who have swung and missed on first round wideouts Reggie Williams, R.Jay Soward and Matt Jones in recent years) addressed another need by tabbing OT Eugene Monroe. The rich got richer in the 2nd round when the Jags selected Arizona OT Eben Britton, who comes in the league with a chip on his shoulder after being passed up in the 1st round. The Jags would address their need at reciever with some nice underrated late round picks like speedy Mike Thomas, record-breaker Jarrett Dillard, and my personal favorite, Rutgers WR Tiquan Underwood. All three will have the fortune of learning from a still-breathing Torry Holt, one of the finest route runners in the game.

4. New York Jets: Lost in the fact that they left this weekend with only three picks was the fact that Gang Green didn't really NEED much. They landed the QB they desperately wanted in USC's Mark Sanchez, whom some had rated higher than top pick Matt Stafford. They moved up again to take hard-charging Iowa RB Shonn Greene, who will inevitably spell the end for camp holdout Thomas Jones. The beauty of both trades was that they didn't have to sell the farm to move up, giving up only a few backups and a 2nd rounder for Sanchez and a couple late round picks for Greene. While the lack of picks over the years will hurt the Jets in the depth department, the team is built to win now, much like head coach Rex Ryan's former team, the Baltimore Ravens, were last year.

5. Seattle Seahawks: Speaking of win now, the Seahawks are another team that put themselves in position for a run. They ignored the hype of Sanchez and the temptation of Crabtree and snagged arguably the best player in this draft in Wake Forest LB Aaron Curry. They helped the O-line out with center/guard Max Unger and got a nice sleeper in WR Deon Butler out of Penn St. The biggest coup for Seattle though was snatching up Denver's 1st round pick next year for a 2nd rounder this year(which Denver used on undersized CB Alphonso Smith). Oh, and it doesn't hurt that they selected a couple of my boys in Rutgers QB Mike Teel(who I'll admit was a huge reach at the top of the 6th but I still believe he has the tools to be an adequate backup in this league) and S Courtney Greene(who is much better than his 7th round standing). While the team could have done more to get younger on the offensive line, the team hopes it can squeeze one more healthy year out of future Hall of Famer Walter Jones, as well as aging stars WR T.J. Houshmanzadeh and QB Matt Hassellback.

Thumbs Down:

1. Dallas Cowboys: This is normally the section where I eat my words, but come on! While props should be given that owner/GM Jerry Jones decided to do an about face from last year's strategy of picking stars out of the police blotter, Jones clearly thinks his team is better than they actually are. Already short-changed thanks to the bogus Roy Williams trade, the Cowboys foolishly opted out of Day 1 altogether, opting to go into Day 2 with 12 picks. Those picks, however, is where I'm a bit sour. Of those 12 selections, all appeared to be reaches and none seem like they'll be able to help the Cowboys in the immediate future. The most notable of the 12 is local product Stephen McGee, a QB out of Texas A & M, who doesn't have much of a chance of starting with Pro Bowl QB Tony Romo in front of him. The team's biggest needs, cornerback and wide reciever, weren't addressed until the final two picks with Cincy CB Mike Mickens and Okalahoma WR Manuel Johnson. Both of whom would be lucky to make the team.

2. Denver Broncos: You would think a guy who spent so many years under the tutleage of draft master Bill Belichick, you would think head coach Josh McDaniels would know a thing or two about building a team. After forcing his 25-year old franchise QB out of town by making googly-eyes at one of his former proteges, McDaniels ignored its huge holes on defense and used its first of two selections on Georgia RB Knowshon Moreno. While Moreno is a solid running back, his selection is a bit of a headscratcher given the fact that THE BRONCOS SIGNED THREE RUNNING BACKS PRIOR TO THE DRAFT! I know the team had some injury problems in the backfield, but clearly, that defense needed more immediate attention. Denver went defense with its 2nd pick in Tennesee DE/LB Robert Ayers, who has legit athleticism and pass-rushing ability....just like former first round flame-out Jarvis Moss. I'm not saying Ayers is going to be a bust, but the team might have been better served going with the significantly more athletic Brian Orakpo at 12, and then using thier 2nd pick on a guy like Rey Maualuga, who would have solidified the middle of that linebacking core. To top it off, the team traded one of its two 1st rounders next year for 5'9 cornerback Alphonso Smith, who, barring injury, will sit behind Champ Bailey and Andre Goodman to start the season. Not exactly a great start to the McDaniels Era.

3. Oakland Raiders: Man, where do I start? While I can understand the reluctance behind taking Texas Tech Micheal Crabtree(possibly slow 40, injured foot, pass happy system), someone is going to have to sit me down and explain to me how Darrius Heyward Bey is the 7th best player in this draft. Despite having guys on the board like Crabtree, OT Eugene Monroe, and DT B.J. Raji, GM/Owner Al Davis stuck with his obsession over 40 times and suprised everyone by taking DHB, who they probably could have traded back into the late first round to grab if they absolutely had to.(Well, not everyone, some mocks had DHB going here as a joke and even I hinted at it in my mock). That was just the start of it. Davis used a 2nd round pick on Ohio S Michael Mitchell, whom draft guru Mel Kiper Jr. had as the 73rd rated player at his position and whom some GMs had rated as an undrafted free agent. 73rd! I know Kiper isn't exactly Bill Parcells, but my God! The rest of the draft consisted of so many no-names, they could be casted for a Bring It On sequel.

4. Draft Time: Look, I love the NFL Draft. It's like Christmas multiplied by Thanksgiving for me, but even I don't believe it has any business running on prime-time...especially during the NBA playoffs. While last year's 3 p.m. start was brutal, the move to 4 p.m. was worse. The main problem with making the Draft so late isn't so much that it runs concurrent with other events(in the age of TiVo, there are ways to not miss an NBA playoff game or a Yankees-Red Sox showdown), it's that it's preceding by hours and hours of pre-draft hype inwhich the networks kill time by going over the same story lines over and over and over again. Where's Mark Sanchez going? Do we need a rookie wage scale? Who's trading up? Who's trading down? It's hyperbole overload. I've championed the idea of moving the draft a few weeks back for years, simply because all that down time leads to miniscule stories reaching the overblown level(particularly this year with all the rampant trade rumors and draft hypotheticals). If you want to keep the Draft in prime time, move it up to March and let it run as an opening act to baseball Opening Night. You can have Day 1 run from 12-8 and then go right into baseball's regular season debut. Otherwise, you'll just have more and more wasted time of talking heads spewing the same headlines over and over again, which brings me to....

5. Where's the sizzle?: Months of trade talk and the best you give me is Ellis Hobbs? What happened to Anquan going to the Eagles? Or Braylon to the Giants? All these "insiders" with their "near-certianties" and the best we got was a 3rd-string cornerback being dealt for a couple of late rounders nobody will remember. Sure, Boldin and Edwards and company could be dealt before the regular season, but after spending the last 12 weeks building up all this rampant talk that has fans salivating over the next big move, we ended up with an Acquisition Cold War. The only way the Draft Day trading scene could have been more disappointing would be if it was hosted by Nic Cage. Not only that, rather than trading their disgruntled stars, GMs decided to spite them as well as the fans by drafting their eventual replacements. The Eagles gave a huge middle finger to Sheldon Brown by trading for Hobbs and bringing in Macho Harris. The Jets brushed Thomas Jones off their shoulders by acquiring Shonn Greene. The Browns started preparing re-tape some new names over Brady Quinn and Braylon Edwards' lockers by drafting two recievers and trading for another quarterback. Worst of all were the Cardinals, who got Boldin more excited than Paula Abdul spotting a bowl full of Percocet by letting all this talk of an inevitable exit linger, only to turn their cell phones off over the weekend.

All in all, it was a respectable weekend. Despite the lack of star power at the top of the draft, teams made things interesting by swinging for the fences. Some teams whiffed and some teams put a few in the stands. While there's never any sure things following the last weekend of April, one thing I can say with great certianty is that the next five months til kickoff will be every bit as agonizing as the previous three were leading up to today.

--Dave

Saturday, April 25, 2009

Christmas Comes Early

If you're a nerd like me,(and chances are, you aren't), then this weekend's NFL Draft is the closest thing to a spring Christmas. No event is more responsible for more false hope than the NFL Draft. One by one, fans get bent out of shape over the acquisition of popular college enigmas in the hopes that these newcomers will lead them to the Promised Land. Another part of the great fun of Draft weekend is the slew of mock drafts that surface from every writer, fan, blogger, "expert" with a pulse. Mock drafts are thrilling because they are completely baseless educated guesses that turn out to be completely meaningless due to its inaccuracies by the end of the 1st round. So, despite the impossibility of a high success rate, I took it upon myself to write one anyway....because what's more fun than having a written excuse to put your foot in your mouth?


1. Detroit Lions: Matt Stafford, QB, Georgia. ESPN is already reporting that Stafford has agreed to a 6 year deal with nearly $42 million guarenteed, so any chance of a curveball at the top is now gone. With the suspense out of the way, Stafford now has all the time in the world to focus on turning around the worst sports franchise in the country and bringing hope to the most dilapidated city in America. No pressure, Matt.

2. St. Louis Rams: Jason Smith, OT, Baylor: (Draft Preface #1: Here is where everything is going to get interesting. After wowing scouts at his Pro Day, USC QB Mark Sanchez has a bunch of teams picking in the middle of the draft all googly-eyed over the idea of bringing him in as their QB of the future. The result has been weeks of smokescreens and trade rumors with contenders piling their chips in order to move up, while pretenders look to save money and fill more holes by moving down. So, really, the top 10 could be littered by some unexpected guests that will inevitably make everything I'm about to write moot. So while this mock has a no-trade policy, keep in mind that there could be, and more than likely will be, some shake-up at the top depending on how far Sanchez falls)-Reports have circulated recently that the Rams offered USC QB Mark Sanchez a plane ticket to St. Louis, which is either a harbinger that Sanchez will be the next Rams QB or a last ditch attempt at garnering interest in a deal. Assuming its the latter, I have the Rams addressing their biggest need, which is left tackle. The Rams pass protection has been abysmal over the last couple years, which has lead to the decline of stars like QB Marc Bulger, RB Stephen Jackson and ex-WR Torry Holt. Having honed his pass-blocking skills at pass happy Baylor, Smith would be an instant upgrade over current incumbant, Alex Barron.

3. Kansas City Chiefs: Tyson Jackson, DE, LSU-As of a couple weeks ago, I was 99% sure this was going to be Wake Forest LB Aaron Curry. However, two things to consider. One, dating back to 2000 when he was with New England, current Chiefs GM Scott Pioli has used a first round pick on a LB once(last year's ROTY Jerod Mayo, whom the Pats traded down to take) so needless to say, Pioli doesn't covet linebackers, especially those who don't rush the passer, this high in the draft. Second, 3-4 ends like Jackson are rare breeds and there are some scouts who compare Jackson to a man Pioli was very familiar with in New England: Pro Bowl DE Richard Seymour. Is #3 a bit high for Jackson? Sure, but so is Curry, and if you're going to reach, you might as well take someone who fits. The perfect scenario for Kansas City would be to call up Redskins owner Dan Snyder and, assuming Mark Sanchez is still available, hope to work out a deal to move into the middle of the draft where they could still select Jackson and pay him less money. Either way, I would bet on Jackson over Curry.

4. Seattle Seahawks: Michael Crabtree, WR, Texas Tech-This pick is where I had the toughest time figuring things out. With possibilities like Curry, Sanchez, Crabtree and UVA OT Eugune Monroe all available, it's hard to make a solid case for one over the others. However, while QB Matt Hassellback is getting old and frail, he still has some game left in him and could be effective if they put a team around him. Could they use a replacement for Walter Jones at left tackle? Sure. Would it be nice to grab Sanchez here? Absolutely. Does Aaron Curry seem like a steal here after being projected to KC for so long? Definitely. However, we seem to forget that Crabtree is viewed by some to be the best player in this draft and, given the Seahawks' recieving woes last season, would be too good of a fit to pass up as an option opposite recent free-agent signing T.J. Houshmanzadeh.

5. Cleveland Browns: Aaron Curry, LB, Wake Forest-With all the hoopla over trades for Braylon Edwards and Brady Quinn, the Browns can quell both fires considerably by selecting the best defensive player in the draft in Curry. While not used as a pass-rusher much at Wake Forest, Curry has the speed and athleticism to be a force in Eric Mangini's 3-4 scheme. While the Browns are hoping for Crabtree to fall to 5 and become Edwards' replacement, I'm sure they'll "settle" for Curry.

6. Cincinatti Bengals: Andre Smith, OT, Alabama-Lost in the running punchline that was the 2008 Bengals was the fact that their defense, which is traditionally horrible, wasn't too shabby last season. Now that they filled a hole in the middle with defensive tackle/Lord of War Tank Johnson, they can focus on their other big issue: offensive line. Much was made about Smith's not-so-flattering Combine, in which he showed up heavy and then left early, but there's no denying the kid can flat-out maul if you light a fire under his ass. With coach Marvin Lewis on the hot seat, I don't think he can pass up the most NFL-ready tackle in the draft if he falls to them.

7. Oakland Raiders: Jeremy Maclin, WR, Missouri-With a reputation for more curveballs than Barry Zito, Raiders GM/owner Al Davis is always a tough nut to crack in terms of predicting just what he'll do on Draft Day. One thing's for sure, nobody is more obsessed with fast 40 times than Old Al. With 4.3 speed, decent size and a surplus of explosiveness, Maclin is the kind of talent that gets Davis all hot and bothered under his track suit....Of course, the same can be said about the slightly faster Darrius Heyward-Bey, whom Davis is supposedly infatuated with, so we'll see how this wild card plays out.

8. Jacksonville Jaguars: B.J. Raji, DT, Boston College(Draft Preface # 2: If Sanchez is still available when the Jags go on the clock, I give Jacksonville a 5% chance of staying at 8, given the desperation of teams like the Broncos at 12, the Redskins at 13 and the Jets at 17. If Sanchez is not available, watch out for the Patriots, who are reportedly interested in jumping into the top 10 and have the cavalcade of Day 1 picks to do it. Either way, don't be suprised if the Jags trade down.) With that being said, if the Jags stick at 8, it would be hard for them to pass up on the disruptive Raji. Having noticed the glaring hole inside after trading away DT Marcus Stroud last year, the Jags can pair Raji with the enormous John Henderson alongside last year's rookie DEs Derrick Harvey and Quentin Groves. If Crabtree or Maclin slide, it will be interesting to see if the Jags go that route after being so unsuccessful taking WRs in the first round in years past.

9. Green Bay Packers: Brian Orakpo, DE/LB, Texas-After losing nearly half their games by a touchdown or less, the Packers come into this offseason with a new defensive philosophy(courtesy of Dom Capers and his 3-4 defense) and a new need: outside linebacker/pass rusher. Luckily for the Packers, The Orak Attack seems to be sliding a little, thanks to the emergence of Mark Sanchez. Word on the street is that Packers GM Ted Thompson has a huge man-crush for Orakpo following his workout last month and would be absolutely ecstatic to land him here. However, given the age of LT Chad Clifton and the possible non-return on Mark Tauscher on the right side, do not be suprised if the Packers go offensive line here.

10. San Francisco 49ers: Eugene Monroe, OT, Virginia-Head coach Mike Singletary is telling anyone that will listen he's fine with the two-headed monster of Alex Smith and Shaun Hill at QB and they have no interest in using this pick on Mark Sanchez or anyone other rookie signal caller(It should be noted that, while Sanchez is available here, the chances of him actually being available when the Niners go on the clock are slim-to-none). Monroe was once considered the top tackle in the draft before the emergence of Jason Smith and the unveiling of Monroe's creaky knees. While the Niners did sign Marvel Smith in the offseason, he's coming off back surgury and, thus, is a bit shaky to last the full season.

11. Buffalo Bills: Michael Oher, OT, Ole Miss-Having hit the jackpot by moving underpaid-yet-overrated LT Jason Peters to Philadelphia, the Bills were able to score a king's ransom, yet also open up a hole. While Oher's poor Combine and Pro Day has his stock falling from once a potential # 1 pick to the 10-20 range, the Bills can ill-afford that Oher or another OT of his caliber will be available when they go up again at 28. If a DE like Brian Orakpo were to fall to 11 though, that could change their mind. Another possibility is Oklahoma St. TE Brandon Pettigrew, whom the Bills are targeting with their 2nd pick.

12. Denver Broncos: Mark Sanchez, QB, USC-While I mentioned in blogs past that it would be foolish for Denver to tab Sanchez as their guy after acquring Kyle Orton in the Jay Cutler trade, the fact of the matter is, coach Josh McDaniels seems to have taken a liking to Sanchez. While I strongly doubt Sanchez falls to 12, the chances of him being a Bronco aren't too bad given the fact that the Broncos main competitors for Sanchez(Washington and the Jets) are less equipped to move up than Denver is. If Denver changes its mind or Sanchez is unavailable, expect them to go defense with both this and their pick from Chicago at 18.

13. Washington Redskins: Aaron Maybin, DE, Penn St.-I have a hard time believing that Dan Snyder won't offer the house to get Mark Sanchez. I'm not saying we could see a Ditka-Ricky Williams kind of deal occur, but it wouldn't suprise me given the fact that they all but torched the bridge with current QB Jason Campbell. However, hypotheticals aside, the Redskins need a pass rusher and Maybin has the most raw potential of any pass rusher in the draft. Only 21, Maybin bulked up prior to Pro Day and still exhibited the speed and athleticism that has him projected all over this draft. If the price to move up for Sanchez is too expensive(which, in Snyder Land, is unlikely), they could stay at home and tab Maybin or another DE here.

14. New Orleans Saints: Brian Cushing, LB, USC-The word out of N.O. is that this is a toss-up between Cushing and Ohio St. RB Chris "Beenie" Wells. While Wells would be the perfect power complement to the speedy Reggie Bush, the Saints might be reluctant to take another RB(an oft-injured one at that) with so many needs on defense and so little picks. If the team is sold on Beenie, there could be the possibility of moving down in the hopes of gaining another pick. As for Cushing, he's the rare type of 4-3 outside linebacker who can wreak havoc rushing the passer, something the Saints could use given its weakness in the secondary.

15. Houston Texans: Malcom Jenkins, CB/FS, Ohio St.-Oh, how the mighty have fallen. Had Jenkins came out last season, he was a sure-fire top 10 pick. Instead, he chased a title at Ohio St. and, like his Buckeye buddies, sees his draft stock plummet thanks to an underwhelming season and an even more disappointing workout at the Combine and Pro Day. However, Jenkins has to be considered a steal at 15 and would make a nice combo when paired with franchised CB Dunta Robinson and free-agent signing Eugene Wilson. While lacking in speed, Jenkins has great size(6'1, 210 lbs) and good instincts, which is a neccesity to a team playing Peyton Manning twice a year.

16. San Diego Chargers: Rey Maualuaga, ILB, USC-With the top OTs off the board, as well as the best 3-4 end in Tyson Jackson, this pick comes down to Maualuga and the Bolts' choice of the top RBs(Wells, Knowshon Moreno, Donald Brown). Having signed LT for another 3 years(though my heart says he plays only 1 more in San Diego) and with Darren Sproles franchised, the Chargers could wait on a young back as opposed to taking an impact linebacker like Maualuga. With his freakish size and speed and his bone-jarring hits, Maualuga seems like the perfect fit on a team that already has the steroid-addled intensity of Shawne "Lights Out" Merriman. With no 2nd rounder, the Chargers could still opt to tab Wells or Moreno here, or more likely, trade down in hopes of picking up and an extra pick.

17. New York Jets: Chris "Beenie" Wells, RB, Ohio St.-While I generally have no clue what ANY of these teams are doing on Draft Day, the Jets in particular has me especially perplexed. With no real needs outside of QB, the Jets could choose to either go all-in and move up for USC's Mark Sanchez, strike a deal for veterans like Jason Campbell or Brady Quinn or stay put and take the best player available. The big wild card at this spot is Kansas St. QB Josh Freeman, who has the most upside but is still very raw and needs time to develop(something that's hard to do in the Metropolitan Area). With RB Thomas Jones turning 31 and heading for decline and backup Leon Washington better suited for 3rd down duty, the team could use a big bruiser like Wells to eventually supplant Jones and work as the Thunder to Washington's Lightning(ala Tiki Barber and Ron Dayne with the Giants nearly a decade ago...which still gives Gabe nightmares). Other options include Maryland WR Darrius Heyward-Bey, UNC's Hakeem Nicks and Georgia's Knowshon Moreno.

18. Denver Broncos(from Chicago): Everette Brown, DE/LB, Florida St.-Having tabbed its QB of the future with Mark Sanchez, the Broncos can now focus on an actual need: defense. While Everette Brown performed well at the Combine and his Pro Day, he's hurt by both his lack of height(6'1) and the stigma of Florida St. defensive ends' lack of success in the NFL(Kamerion Wimbley, Jamal Reynolds, Andre Wadsworth). With most of the top pass rushers gone, Brown still represents value here, as he is still considered a possible top 10 pick by some. Other possibilities are Ole Miss DT Peria Jerry, USC LB Clay Matthews, and Tennesee DE Robert Ayers.

19. Tampa Bay Bucs: Peria Jerry, DT, Ole Miss-Maybe it's just me, but I find the idea of the Bucs still possibly taking Kansas St. QB Josh Freeman after just signing Byron Leftwich a couple weeks ago just a wee bit confusing. Sure, Leftwich is not exactly a franchise QB at 28(and on his 4th team, no less) and certianly Freeman could sit out Leftwich 2-year deal and then take over when Leftwich is a free agent, but what happens if Leftwich succeeds? And why have Josh Johnson and Luke McCown on the roster if you're taking another QB? All these legit questions aside, I went with Jerry here because he fills a more immediate need. With the team lacking an inside presence since Warren Sapp left and having released most, if not all, of its stars on defense, the team can afford to bring in some new help.....that is, of course, if they don't squander this pick on Freeman.

20. Detroit Lions(from Dallas): Robert Ayers, DE, Tennesee-With Stafford signed, sealed and delivered, the Lions can now focus their attention on making that silly Roy Williams trade look even more lop-sided in their favor. While the Lions would love one of the top OT to fall here, they might have to settle for Ayers, whose stock is on the rise after a solid Pro Day and would fit in nicely in new coach Jim Schwartz's scheme.

21. Philadelphia Eagles: Brandon Pettigrew, TE, Oklahoma St. (Draft Preface # 3: Two things to look out for at this point of the draft. First, if Kansas St. QB Josh Freeman is still available here, these next 6-7 picks could be trade bait for teams at the top of the 2nd looking to move back in to grab the last potential franchise QB. Secondly, the Cardinals are still actively shopping WR Anquan Boldin, and while its believed the price has dropped to a 2nd rounder and other late round considerations, it's not unlikely for a team to offer a 1st in an attempt to trump other offers)-With only two of the top WRs gone and only one top RB taken, you would think Andy Reid would use this pick to take a WR or RB.....and you would be wrong. Here are the facts. Reid's never taken a RB higher than the 3rd(and that includes current franchise back Brian Westbrook) and has taken a WR in the 1st once(the laughably horrible Freddie "FredEx" Mitchell). In fact, assuming that the Eagles would take Pettigrew is a stretch given the history of the team's unwillingness to use high picks to help out QB Donovan McNabb. The more likely scenario would be swapping with Buffalo or a team at the top of the 2nd round and taking Cal center Alex Mack. If, for some chance, the pick is Pettigrew, he has the type of size to be a factor over the middle for McNabb. Also, unlike predecessor L.J. Smith, Pettigrew has reliable hands and is a solid blocker.

22. Minnesota Vikings: Josh Freeman, QB, Kansas St.-While I'd find it more likely for the Vikes to take Huey Freeman than Josh Freeman, the fact remains that a. Freeman's the best player available and b. the Vikings need a QB(For further info into this topic, see Gabe's blog about Brad Childress from earlier this month). With Tarvaris Jackson and Sage Rosenfels(whom the Vikes traded for and signed to a decent sized contract) on the roster, Freeman would be a longshot here, but he would be an upgrade. Like the proposed scenario in Tampa Bay, Freeman could stand to learn a thing or two by waiting out the incumbent's contract and then inevitably taking over when he's ready. While it's more likely Minnesota will go OT or maybe even WR, they could be a prime candidate in Draft Preface # 3. Another situation to watch will be the QBs that come available after the Mark Sanchez Sweepstakes is over.

23. New England Patriots: Larry English, DE/LB, Northern Illinois-Armed with 4 picks inside the first 60 selections, the Pats have made it known they're looking to move up to land a premier talent as opposed to a group of lesser worker bees. Could this mean a deal for disgruntled Panthers DE Julius Peppers? Doubtful, but it's something worth looking into. With nothing behind QB and playoff rally killer Jake Delhomme, the team could dangle Peppers with the hope of getting back into the first round to nab a guy like Josh Freeman if he's there. While Peppers would command the kind of big contract the Pats generally avoid, you'd have to believe Peppers' contract demands won't be much different than those of a top 10 pick. As for English, he would bring back the pass rush vacated by the departure of Mike Vrabel and is the type of raw talent that the Pats have molded into gold over the years.

24. Atlanta Falcons: Evander "Ziggy" Hood, DT, Missouri-Having addressed its need for a TE by stealing Hall of Famer Tony Gonzalez from the Chiefs, the Falcons can focus on addressing their needs on defense, most importantly, on the defensive line. Having wisely passed up Glenn Dorsey for Matt Ryan last year, the Dirty Birds still have a gaping hole inside and Hood, whose stock is moving up, is the type of big body to fill it. Another option here could be UConn's Darius Butler and Illinois' Vontae Davis, both cornerbacks, who could fill the spot left by DeAngelo Hall and most recently, Dominique Foxworth.

25. Miami Dolphins: Clay Matthews, LB, USC-While this would be a prime spot for the Phins to snag a reciever to pair with Ted Ginn Jr, the more likely scenario would be targeting two of Parcells' most coveted positions: linebacker and cornerback. Like his USC linebacker mates, Matthews is extremely athletic and would make a nice pair with aging Joey Porter. While it's possible a curveball like Hakeem Nicks or Kenny Britt could be the pick, the only other realistic option would a cornerback like Darius Butler or Alphonso Smith.

26. Baltimore Ravens: Hakeem Nicks, WR, UNC-With the price tag on Cardinals WR Anquan Boldin decreased, it's possible the Ravens swing a deal for Boldin and use this pick to get younger on defense. However, with no deal on the table as of yet, the Ravens get their choice of Nicks, Rutgers' Kenny Britt and local boy Darrius Heyward Bey. With Derrick Mason aging and not much behind him and Mark Clayton, the need for a pass catcher has become a top priority. On a side note, my sole purpose for opting for Nicks over Britt is because the idea of my friend Carlos' Ravens acquring ANOTHER one of my beloved Scarlet Knights would sicken me to the point where I might not leave the bed til Christmas.

27. Indianapolis Colts: Darrius Heyward-Bey, WR, Maryland-The Colts can go a number of ways here. They could address the offensive line with guys like Arizona's Eban Britton, Oklahoma's Phil Loadholt and Duke Robinson or Cal's Alex Mack. I went with DHB here because the Colts favor the 3 WR set and, without Marvin Harrison, they could use another speedy threat to add to Peyton Manning's arsenal. Also, in continuing to beat this scenario into the ground, keep an eye out for Josh Freeman, not just as trade bait, but as the possible heir apparent to Mr. Laser Rocket Arm.

28. Buffalo Bills(from Philadelphia): Michael Johnson, DE, Georgia Tech-Best case scenario for the Bills is TE Brandon Pettigrew, whom they are considering at # 11, falling here. However, the team has needs on the defensive line. Unable to muster a pass rush outside of DE Aaron Schobel, the team needs an influx of quality lineman. While Johnson's rep for being somewhat lazy could drop him down to the late 2nd-early 3rd area, the Bills could use the extra pick here to snag a project with incredible upside. Johnson is 6'7, with a 4.4 40, and with the right push, could be the next Julius Peppers. This late in the round, he could be worth the gamble.

29. New York Giants: James Laurinitis, LB, Ohio St.-With Plaxico Burress gone, the team is searching a true # 1 WR to be a shot in the arm(or leg) for this team. However, the draft only has one true # 1 and that's Michael Crabtree, who needless to say will not be available at 29. It also should be mentioned that the Giants have stocked up on young WRs the last few drafts and while Steve Smith, Mario Manningham, Sinorice Moss and Dominik Hixon don't have the big play ability of Plax, they might be enough to usher Big Blue from taking a WR(at least, until they acquire Braylon Edwards from Cleveland). Laurinitis, like his teammate Malcom Jenkins, could have made himself some serious coin had he came out last year, but inevitiably stayed and killed his draft stock. With his athleticism and instinct, he could be a nice fit on the inside or outside for a Giants team still searching for another Jessie Armstead.

30. Tennesee Titans: Kenny Britt, WR, Rutgers- Every year, mock drafters like myself sucker ourselves into thinking the Titans will finally address their need at reciever by taking a wideout in the first frame. Every year, they make us into liars. While Britt would represent excellent value at this pick and has the best potential to be a # 1 WR of the group of guys not named Mike Crabtree, the fact is, this pick will probably not be Kenny Britt. The more likely scenario is the Titans taking an interior lineman like Alex Mack or Oregon St.'s Max Unger or continuing to irritate former ROTY Vince Young by taking another QB like, yup, you guessed it, Josh Freeman.

31. Arizona Cardinals: Knowshon Moreno, RB, Georgia-Outside of Crabtree and my boy Kenny Britt, I think Knowshon Moreno might be among the best players in this draft. However, given last year's huge class of running backs and the lack of need this year, Moreno is somewhat of a draft enigma. On the one hand, he makes great sense for a team like Denver at 12, or San Diego at 16 or the Jets at 17, but the Mark Sanchez circus makes it hard for anyone to envision Moreno going to any of those places. With Edge James on the way out and Tim Hightower better suited for part-time duty, the Cards could use another weapon in their high octane offense. While Moreno doesn't possess outer-worldly speed, he has great vision and is dangerous in the open field. He's also a solid reciever out of the backfield, something QB Kurt Warner will need after Anquan Boldin is traded.

32. Pittsburgh Steelers: Eben Britton, OT, Arizona-When you're the champs, you can pretty much go for the best player available. Lucky for the Steelers, Eban Britton represents both value and need. With their bookend tackles unsigned, the team could take advantage of a deep OT class to help keep Big Ben upright and avoid last year's turnstile O-Line. Another option is 6'3 Utah CB/S Sean Smith, who could replace departed CB Bryant McFadden opposite Ike Taylor or fill in for Troy Polamalu when he inevitably succumbs to The Madden Curse(Sorry, Sean).


---Dave

Thursday, April 2, 2009

When It's Over....

Now that we have closure on the story that has been beaten worse than Rihanna at a Grammy after party, here are my closing thoughts on today's blockbuster trade sending Jay Cutler to the Bears:

1. Whether it was the fear of being outbid by other teams or GM Jerry Angelo getting conned by Denver's asking price, I can't help but think the Bears overpaid for Cutler. Two first rounders, a 3rd and a starting quarterback for a guy with a losing record as a starter coming off his first Pro Bowl season who just pissed and moaned his way out of town? I understand that 25-year old quarterbacks with a lot of football left in them come at a premium but was Kyle Orton that bad last year that the Bears absolutely HAD to have Cutler? Cutler's presence has given the city of Chicago what it's been force-fed for 100 years: false hope. It seems like wishful thinking that a guy, whose numbers are a bit inflated due to a superior supporting cast and solid offensive line, will make a team with no true # 1 reciever and a shaky offensive line into an instant contender in a division in which you have to believe all three other teams are bound to improve. Two firsts and a third in this league can get almost anybody and with the Bears' need for a top reciever, it seems silly to me that Angelo couldn't just offer the same package to Arizona in exchange for WR Anquan Boldin. Boldin is the type of tough, physical reciever that would fit it well in a rough and tumble city like Chicago and would be a great complement to freakish speedster Devin Hester. If you're a Bears fan, would you rather have Kyle Orton throwing to Boldin and Hester or Jay Cutler throwing to Hester and.......Earl Bennett? Cutler's presence gives them an upgrade at QB, but it sure doesn't make them contenders. Speaking of wishful thinking, it seems mighty hopeful for the Bears to think they'll get three quality years out of oft-injured, 9-time Pro Bowl left tackle Orlando Pace.

2. So where do the Broncos go from here? Rumors have circulated that Denver has interest in USC QB Mark Sanchez, but that might be a smoke screen. Why would GM Brian Xanders and owner Pat Bowlen be so adamant on having a quarterback be included on any deal for Cutler if they were planning on tabbing Sanchez all along? And let's not write off Kyle Orton being a success in Denver. He's stepping into a weaker division, with a significantly better offensive line and recieving core. Orton went for 3,000 yards and 18 touchdowns playing behind a line that gave up 29 sacks and with his # 1 reciever being a reformed cornerback/kick returner. Imagine what he can do with Brandon Marshall, Eddie Royal and some time to throw. The best move for Denver would be to rebuild that horrible defense and this draft is stockpiled with defensive talent. Picking 12th and 18th, the Broncos could have a shot at guys like Boston College defensive tackle B.J. Raji, USC inside linebacker Rey Maualuga and Ohio St. defensive back Malcom Jenkins, to name a few. If Orton fails to pan out, the Broncos are armed with two firsts next year to move up to snag one of the two prized franchise quarterbacks in next year's draft: Heisman winner Sam Bradford of Oklahoma and Texas' Colt McCoy. Let's also not forget Florida's Tim Tebow, who could be a interesting weapon in McDaniels' creative schemes.

3. The big loser in this mess has to be Jay Cutler. He trades in a world-class supporting cast and the oppurtunity to shine under the tuteledge of one of the NFL's brightest, young offensive minds for the chance to run for his life in the impatient Windy City. Cutler's arrival already sparks hope of Super Bowl aspirations for the Chicago faithful and it will be interesting to see how someone as thin-skinned as Cutler can handle the boo-birds if he gets off to a slow start. While it's understandable to be a bit heartbroken when you're surprised by unexpected trade rumors, you have to wonder if this was all worth it for Cutler? Because of his steep price tag, the Bears won't be able to build around Cutler for at least the next two years and the fact that his blind side is being covered by the clearly declining Pace can't be too reassuring for a guy who was only sacked 12 times last year. Cutler has three years remaining on his rookie contract and his PR can't take another hit if he attempts to whine his way out of town again. So now Cutler faces the harsh price of being unwilling to swallow his pride in a cutthroat business by being forced to play the role of savior for a team with bleak future.

4. With Cutler off the market, this opens the door for the other teams and players on the outside looking in of the Cutler Sweepstakes. The Lions will no doubt tab Georgia QB Matt Stafford with their first pick, with the hopes of finding him some protection later in the draft. The Jets will probably make an attempt at one of the two notable free agent QBs: Byron Leftwich and Jeff Garcia(though Garcia is a long-shot). Tampa Bay will probably try its damnedest to select Kansas State QB Josh Freeman and rebuild around him. If Sanchez doesn't end up in Denver, there's the more likely scenario of him going to San Francisco with the 10th pick(or an even bigger curveball, Seattle at # 4). An interesting scenario to watch will be Washington, who for some peculiar reason were more interested than need-be in Cutler and now face the possibility of an unhappy Jason Campbell now that word has gotten out.

Until next time, your favorite blogger's favorite blogger.....Dave Leonardis